What Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups Taught Me About Grant Management

May 29, 2025 | Grant Writing

What Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups Taught Me About Grant Management Thumbnail Image

Grant Readiness: It’s About Way More Than Just Writing

When most people think about grants, they immediately jump to “grant writing.” While writing is critical to the process, it’s one piece of a much larger puzzle. The secret to grant success is to be grant-ready before your fingers touch a keyboard to beat an oncoming deadline.

Grant readiness and grant management are the coming together of the chocolate and peanut butter that makes the guilty pleasure known as the Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup. It’s the combination that makes the flavors sing.

Setting Strategic Priorities (Not Just Chasing Money)

Here’s where many organizations go wrong: they start with available funding and try to fit their programs into whatever grants they find. Skipping the step of setting funding priorities could lead to a severe case of mission drift, where an agency skids from one grant opportunity to another without pausing to consider whether they are truly good fits.  This leads to organizations constantly scrambling, staff burnout, and ineffective programs.

Instead, start with what members of the communities you serve need to succeed. That will determine funding priorities to grow, expand, augment, or start programs and projects.

Whether grants are the right form of revenue for those priorities depends on what you need most. For example, most agencies could use more admin staff but grants rarely cover those positions. You’d be better off pursuing individual donors, special events, or monthly giving programs for that type of support. Amanda and I detail how grant cycles work and offer suggestions for building a grant-ready library of the most commonly requested documents in the latest episode of the Fundraising HayDay Podcast HERE.

Building Your Grant Team

Successful grant development isn’t a solo act but requires team effort. The size and structure of your team will depend on your organization’s size, but every grant-seeking program needs to address these key roles:

For Larger Organizations

Consider establishing a formal Grants Task Force with these components:

(1) Funding Priorities Team: Senior Leadership, Development Director or Chief Development Officer, Grants Officer, and Finance representative

(2) Grant Writing Team: Project Director, Grant Writer, and an Editing Committee for quality control

(3) Budget and Management Team: CFO or Staff Accountant, Program Manager, Development Director, Grant Writer, plus input from direct service staff

For Smaller Organizations

Your team might be streamlined to just three key players, but they need to work closely together:

  • Grant Writer or Development Director
  • Finance Director or Bookkeeper
  • Program Director

These three people collaborate on everything from identifying priorities and defining programs to building budgets and managing reporting requirements.

Beyond the Paperwork

Grant readiness and grant management aren’t just about having the right documents in the right folders. It’s about having solid operations, strong community connections, and systems that can handle the requirements that come with grant funding.

This means having financial systems that can track restricted funds separately, staff who understand compliance requirements, and programs already making a measurable impact in your community. It means having relationships with community partners who can serve as collaborators or provide letters of support.

Before you start pursuing that next grant opportunity, take a step back. Do you have your priorities straight? Is your team in place? Are your documents organized? Do you have the operational infrastructure to handle grant requirements?

If you can answer yes to these questions, then you’re truly grant ready. And that’s when the grants become a strategic tool for advancing your mission rather than a source of stress and scrambling to meet deadlines.

Combining grant readiness and grant management as one concept truly makes the whole greater than the sum of its parts—just like a peanut butter cup!

Kimberly Hays de Muga
Latest posts by Kimberly Hays de Muga (see all)
Fundraising HayDay

A podcast about grants & such.

Check out all our episodes, and don’t miss any new ones, by subscribing on Apple Podcasts or Spotify today!

Spotify Podcast button.
Apple Podcast button.

Latest Episode

The Fundraising HayDay Podcast charted on the 90 Best Fundraising Podcast list compiled by Feedspot . In fact, we landed at spot #4.

Thanks to our listeners and supporters! This is such a passion project for us, and we trust you love it as much as we do.

You can find the entire lineup of 90 podcasts by clicking here.

Times are tough. Finding trusted information shouldn’t be. Get our weekly newsletter.